Can You Freeze Whoopie Pies?

What is this and how to preserve it? All information in one place

Written by Elisa Chan. Updated on What is this and how to preserve it All information in one place

Chocolatey, gooey, soft, with delicious filling, these enormously tasty treats are best when being homemade. There is nothing fancy about them since such a dessert can be easily made even by a newbie home chef. Nevertheless, these simple cookies with the filling will fit any occasion. 

No wonder that people often get curious about how to extend the lifespan of these sweet treats and make them stay the same tasty longer.

So can you freeze whoopie pies? Yes, you can freeze whoopies. Baked whoopie pies will stay consumable for the period of up to 3 months if properly stored in a fridge. Wrap them up, each pie should be wrapped separately, and put them into a freezer. When whoopie pie is wrapped it better preserves the taste.

Is it what interests you, too? Then you have come to the right place for getting the answers!

What Are These Whoopies?

Whoopie pie is a sort of baked cookie that takes its origin from the United States. It consists of two round mound-shape pieces of cake with some sweet creamy filling joining them. Originally, the cake is chocolate, however, later variations may include gingerbread cookies, pumpkin pie, or any other flavored baked goodies.

This sweet treat can be shaped like a sandwich, a pie, or as a cake. Initially, they were said to come from New England, but nowadays this dessert is widely made and gladly consumed all over the United States.

How Long Do Whoopie Pies Last?

Since these cookies contain butter-based filling and eggs, many people get concerned about their term of consumption. Do whoopie pies need to be refrigerated, they ask? 

Indeed, such ingredients don’t contribute much to the endless storage term, and the lifespan of the dessert will hang much upon how to store whoopie pies. 

If you wonder how to store homemade or commercially produced whoopie pies, consider the following facts:

  • They are best enjoyed when freshly made
  • Since the goodies have buttercream, they can easily spoil when not chilled. Either refrigerate or frost them hanging upon how soon the dessert will be eaten
  • When refrigerated, the whoopie cookies will stay edible for ten days approximately
  • Exposure to frost can preserve them for half a year the longest, but for keeping the better quality, we would recommend finishing them within two months

Storing whoopie pies in a pantry or on the counter are not allowed since the buttery filling will spoil in a blink of an eye, and that can have quite an unpleasant aftermath for those who will it this. Leave them out for twenty-four hours at most and toss to the fridge if not planning to consume soon.

And how long do whoopie pies last? Whoopie pies last for up to 3 months if properly kept in a freezer. The quality of frozen whoopie pies doesn’t change and they remain consumable. To prolong the lifespan of the pies, wrap each pie before putting it into a freezer.

What Are These Whoopies
Photo by Toa Heftiba

What About Spoilage?

Yes, whoopie cakes can go bad just like any other foodstuff. Since they contain the buttery creamy filling, it makes them perceptive to the warmth of all kinds, as well as temperature fluctuations. 

For this reason, to keep your beloved yummy delicious and safe to eat, never leave it on the table. It is only allowed to cool them down after taking out from the oven.

If it so happened that these chocolate treats spent a lot of time out, check them for the basic sign of spoilage which is the cream decay.

How Long Do Whoopie Pies Last
Photo by MJ Tangonan

 If the filling has a weird taste or smell, or if its appearance makes you doubt about the quality of the goodie, better toss them away.

Also, if the expiry date passed a long time ago, don’t play Russian roulette, discard the potentially spoiled foodstuff.

Is Freezing Whoopie Pies Possible?

What About Spoilage
Photo by Alex Loup

Naturally, since this dessert is so easy to bake and pleasant to enjoy, everyone would like to keep its quality the best longer. The cheering news is that whoopies can actually be preserved in a frosting camera, and freezing affects them quite well.

Just like with any other foodstuff, preserving these sandwich cookies will need certain skills and knowledge, but we will share the basic requirements with you.

To begin with, let’s take a closer look at the positive and negative sides of the preservation process so that you know what to expect.

Upsides to exposing whoopie pies to frost

  • It is possible to make large batches and stock them individually
  • It is easy to take one or two cookies when needed instead of defrosting a whole packet
  • These treats are delicious even when chilled!
  • They are easy to freeze
  • When left in a frosting camera, these sandwich cookies will effortlessly stay consumable for months
  • Exposure to frost usually doesn’t influence the quality and texture of the dessert
  • When consuming them chilled, they will be even less messy than when eaten fresh 
Homemade Apple Pie Recipe  - How to Freeze Apple Pie Video | RadaCutlery.comHomemade Apple Pie Recipe – How to Freeze Apple Pie Video |

Wait, somebody might say, if there are upsides, then downsides must exist, too. Yes, that’s right, whoopie pies have certain disadvantages of being exposed to frost:

  • When being warmed, they will become sticky or crumbly
  • Some fillings will freeze better than others and it takes time and patience to figure that out
  • It is easy to get addicted to chilled treats!

In general, no nasty downsides can be mentioned since this dessert is very frost-friendly, unlike many other sweet treats.

So what about actually freezing?

Is Freezing Whoopie Pies Possible
Photo by kaouther djouada

The procedure is extremely simple and even a child can do this.

  1. Decide whether a batch will be frozen or you would prefer them to be preserved individually. It will not affect the method of freezing, it’s just for you to know whether to sort them or not.
  2. The next stage is to cover each creamy sandwich pie with a plastic film, even if the plan is to preserve a whole batch. Like that, the cookies will be saved from sticking to each other.
  3. Place those individually wrapped pieces either into the frost-friendly packets or to the airtight tanks.
  4. Mark the tanks/packets by writing the date they were frosted. It will help to enjoy the goodies while they are still the best.

When being properly packed, whoopie pies can easily remain preserved in a frosting camera for up to half a year.

How to Defrost Whoopie Pie

Defrost Them Right
Photo by Fallon Michael

These cookies are good in all possible ways: they are simple to make, easy to keep, and the same easy to preserve. But the best thing about them is that no efforts will have to be made to defrost them! In fact, two different options exist hanging upon how you would like to consume them:

  1. Feel free to eat the chilled right from the frosting camera! This is the only dessert we know (for now) that can be eaten like that. Besides, when consumed this way, these creamy treats will most likely leave way less mess compared to the freshly baked counterparts.
  2. Option number two is to defrost them. Simply unwrap the cookies and let them sit on the counter for up to ah hour.

So how to defrost whoopie pie? To defrost whoopie pie, take them out of the freezer, unwrap and leave in the fridge overnight. You can also take pies out of the freezing camera, unwrap them and leave them on the counter for an hour or more to defrost.

The only thing that must be remembered is that whoopie pies will get messier if left out for a long time. It happens because the creamy filling gets softer and gooier which increases the chances of it to leak out when you bite the pie.

But in fact, the oozing threat is the only issue that may happen when dealing with the defrosted cookies like that.

As you can see, these chocolate and cream-filled delicious treats are not only easy to make, they are also super simple to stock. Nevertheless, even then it is necessary to be attentive and follow the major suggestions to make them last longer.

Frequently Asked Questions

⭐ Why do they call it a whoopie pie?

The legend says that when these cookies were first made by Amish women and their families tried those, they exclaimed “whoopie!” being very delighted.

⭐ Why do my whoopie pies come out flat?

The consistency of the batter is the reason. It must be very stiff.

⭐ Who made the first whoopie pie?

The most popular version is that Amish women invented the recipe.

⭐ What is whoopie pie filling made of?

It’s made of butter, sugar, and marshmallow cream.

⭐ What is the difference between a whoopie pie and a Moon Pie?

Whoopie is made of two pieces of cake with the filling between, whereas Moon pie is closer to actual cookies.

⭐ Is whoopie pie a cake or a cookie?

It is closer to cake since it uses chocolate cake parts.

Written by
Elisa is a passionate cook who will advise you on healthy and delicious food topics! With her help, you will discover how to properly store and freeze food, as well as learn important nuances about preserving vitamins in your meals to make them stay nutritious.
Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here.
Delicious Whoopie Pies RecipeDelicious Whoopie Pies Recipe